[Verse 1]
Running under the street lights
Dripping moon-covered water
You said, "How far's the house?"
I said, "Just a little bit farther"
How'd I get the courage back then to get you to notice me?

[Verse 2]
You swing me on the tire
How could I ever get tired of you?
Mosey through the forest
You say "pretty," I scream "gorgeous"
How'd I get the courage back then to get you to notice me?

[Pre-Chorus]
Can't be summer, won't be spring
I'll be somewherе in the middle, in-between
Makе me call out for you, make me scream
I only hear you through the whispers of the trees

[Chorus]
It's make-believe
Hmm, hey, hey, hey
It's make-believe
Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey
[Post-Chorus]
I said I'll pick you up and you didn't believe me
Can you tell me something that'll make it easier?
Easier

[Verse 3]
Are we too old to be this young?
Turn the lights on, it's a marathon
Took the long way home, wasting time with you
It's a miracle, miracle

[Pre-Chorus]
Can't be summer, won't be spring
I'll be somewhere in the middle, in-between
Make me call out for you, make me scream
I only hear you through the whispers of the trees

[Chorus]
It's make-believe
Hmm, hey, hey, hey
It's make-believe
Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey

[Outro]
Bird call, found them in the valley
Clean boys, but we sweat like athletes
Got my whole heart
Got my whole heart
Nothing at all, nothing on you, you, you
First time
First time
My first time