[Verse 1]
You messed it up a million ways
The first one was blaming it on me
You put it to me every which way but the facts won't change
It's safe to say

[Refrain]
So why do you care now?
Why do you care now?
After all you've said and done

[Verse 2]
Told me that I wasn't what you wanted me to be
Had other plans and you throw them out so lightly
'Cause you're meant to be the one I'm running to
And the cracks appear and my own mind tries to fight me

[Refrain]
So why do you care now?
Why do you care now?
After all you've said and done

[Chorus]
'Cause you're in my passenger seat
When you should be in my rearview
Maybe all of my emotions are messed up because of you
And you could paint this picture a thousand different ways
But the fact is you're just so damn out of date
[Verse 3]
It's funny how you wanna help me fix myself
But the problem is five foot five, red hair, it's you
'Cause honey, you're the only catalyst
And the words you're spitting out are just not true

[Refrain]
So why do you care now?
Why do you care now?
After all you've said and done

[Chorus]
'Cause you're in my passenger seat
When you should be in my rearview
Maybe all of my emotions are messed up because of you
And you could paint this picture a thousand different ways
But the fact is you're just so damn out of date

[Bridge]
But how can I let go
Of the only love I've known
But your ignorance is not bliss
For anyone, anyone

[Interlude]
[Chorus]
You're in my passenger seat
When you should be in my rearview
Maybe all of my emotions are messed up because
You're in my passenger seat
When you should be in my rearview
Maybe all of my emotions are messed up because
You're in my passenger seat
When you should be in my rearview
Maybe all of my emotions are messed up because
You're in my passenger seat
When you should be in my rearview
Maybe all of my emotions are messed up because of you