[Verse 1]
Baby, I know that I was wrong in every way
And suddenly, now I've realized
What you were tryin' to say
'Cause all the feelings I've been hidin'
Finally broke your heart one day
So now I'm

[Chorus]
Keepin' the secret to myself
I never wanted to know for sure
Love is a mystery

[Verse 2]
I heard our song, it was playin' last night on the radio
But since you've been gone
It doesn't sound right to me anymore
All this time, I've been denyin'
Lyin' to myself again
So now I'm

[Chorus]
Keepin' the secret to myself
I never wanted to know for sure
Love is a mystery
[Bridge]
Love is a mystery
Until you find the key
Oh, how I keep holdin' on
All because I know, yes, I do, baby
That I won't be the only one
The lonely one

[Chorus]
Keepin' the secret to myself
I never wanted to know for sure
Love is a mystery

[Outro]
Love is a mystery
Love is a mystery
Love is a mystery until you find the key
Love is a mystery (Keepin' the secret to myself)
Love is a mystery
Love is a mystery