[Verse 1: Fabiana Palladino]
You're a mystery
And every time I try
To find out your mystery
You won't confide
When you go away
I follow you in my dreams
To another place
Out in the in-between
You're a mystery
Keeping your secrets safe
I don't know what's up
You don't have to worry babe
You're like a song
One with a melody
And the lighter door
Is locked and I've lost the key

[Chorus: Fabiana Palladino]
You're a mystery
But somehow you belong to me
Out in the pouring rain
Will you call my name?
Or will you run away?

[Verse 2: Fabiana Palladino]
You're a mystery
I knew it right from the start
Don't know why I thought
I could shine a light into the dark
Just come back to me
Don't wait another day
Come back to me
Don't make me feel this way
Is there somewhere out there
Somewhere you'd rather be
Is there someone else
Someone you'd rather see
In the failing light
I can't wait forever baby
There's a future here
Where somehow you feel the same
[Second Chorus: Fabiana Palladino & Jai Paul]
You're a mystery
But somehow I belong to you
Out in the pouring rain
Will you call my name?
Or will you run away?
Deep in this lover's game
Tell me now
Do you feel my pain?
What will you give away?

[Outro: Fabiana Palladino & Jai Paul]
La la la la la la la la la
(Why don't you call me now?)
La la la la la la la la la
Ooh
(Why don't you call me now?)
La la la la la la la la la
Ooh
(Won't you call me?)
(Why don't you call me now?)
La la la la la la la la la
Won't you call me now?