[Verse]
We made love
After watching Forest Gump in my living room
You were wearing cowboy boots while I went down on you
"That Crazy Feeling"
"Coney Island Baby"
Roller coaster ride
On my birthday
You were dancing like a freak
I hid the cocaine
While you kissed me on the cheek
In the photo booth
Pull me close to you
Do you still have it?
The photo?
I know you do

[Chorus]
And I think you are the best thing
This side of the Mississippi
Why did we stop believing in the magic that we were missing?

[Verse]
We both had crushes on that guy from that one band
You have pictures on your wall by your nightstand
You were romancing my best friend while I was gone
I did the same could you blame me we lost it all
[Bridge]
I really miss your accent
I miss the way you dress
I heard you took it back
The note you left in my bed
She likes boys when they're in a band
Clementine in her hand
She was mine
For a time
Now she makes me cry

[Chorus]
I hit the road
Hit the pipe dream
I was flying but then it hit me
Why did we stop believing in the magic that we were missing?

[Instrumental]