[Verse 1]
I always knew I was your favorite mistake
A lost cause because of all the other ones
I see you standing on the edge of last Summer
I feel the friction in the moves that you make
The push-pull is pulling me apart these days
I see you standing apart from one another

[Chorus]
I shook you like you wanted me to
But you didn't feel it
I shook you like you wanted me to
But you didn’t feel it

[Verse 2]
I close my eyes and I can see your future
The sky fell and only it was you and I
The sky fell and we both felt each other
You ask me now "Is that thе same old feeling?"
I look at you and say "It never wеnt away"
Bull, you're just a case I couldn't discover

[Chorus]
I shook you like you wanted me to
But you didn’t feel it
I shook you like you wanted me to
But you didn't feel it
And now I'm shaking, oh I'm shaking
Stop this heart of mine
I shook you like you wanted me to

[Bridge: Elaine Bradley]
I would put you out to the cold ground
[?] but you won't care
I need your love but you won't ever
Be there, be there
I put you out, I won't ever find
I'm a lover, not a fighter
?
Don’t you let me down
Be there, be there

And I was shaking, I was shaking
Stop this heart of mine
I shook you like you wanted me to

[Outro]
I shook you, I shook you
I shook you like you wanted
I shook you, I shook you
I shook you like you wanted
I shook you, I shook you
I shook you like you wanted
I shook you, I shook you