Original Cast of His Story the Musical
From the Moment
[JOSEPH]
From the moment our eyes met
My heart said "hello"
And now that I’ve held you
I never wanna let go
I never wanna let go
Did you let go? Did you let go?
Did you let go?

[MARY]
No!

At the moment our eyes met
My heart said "I don't know”
But now that you've held me
I never wanna let go

[JOSEPH]
Don’t want you to let go

[MARY]
I Never wanna let go, did I let go?
Did I let go? Did I let go?
No, no, no

So just wait a minute and hold me
Bite your lip as I tell you what He told me
Terrified be filled with joy
Joseph save a smile for your baby boy
[JOSEPH]
What?

[MARY]
I will explain you just have to trust me
Expecting, yet no one has touched me
An angel of the Lord appeared and said
A baby will be born of the Spirit

So what do you think?

[JOSEPH]
Mary know I say this with hesitation
But I got to represent His reputation
Yes I am shakin’, it's a lot to take in
I won't move ‘til I know I'm not mistaken

[MARY]
Yes ok then, babe I guess that makes sense
The first thing that love is is patient
So I will wait then I will be waiting
For our sake then Joseph get prayin’

It's all gonna be ok
It's all gonna be alright
Right?
[JOSEPH]
Mary goodnight

[MARY]
Goodnight

[JOSEPH]
What on earth, is she crazy?
A virgin giving birth to a baby!
Did she somehow do this
For the sake of her advantage?
Was I stupid and let some fool take advantage?

Why? Is it a lie?
I can't get her brown eyes out of my mind
Was it my fault, was it me?
Did I not love her enough
To the point that she'd cheat?

Why God, why this?
Why give herself to some man
And then blow me a kiss?
God! What should I do now?
It seems there's one thing left to do now

Should I follow the Law and gather the stones?
No, Mary didn't know
She didn’t know, she didn’t know that
From the moment our eyes met
My heart said hello
But God if she loved me
Why would she let go?
Why would she let go, did she let go
Did she let go, did she let go?

[ANGEL]
So just wait a minute and listen
Bite your lip as I tell you ‘bout His mission
Terrified be filled with joy
Joseph save a smile for your baby boy

[JOSEPH]
What?

[ANGEL]
I will explain, you just have to trust her
Expecting, yet no one has touched her
I'm an angel of the Lord don't fear
This Baby will be born of the Spirit
I know that it's a lot, much being scary
But God be with you

[JOSEPH]
I have to find Mary!
I have to find Mary!

[MARY]
From the moment our eyes met
My heart said I don’t know
But Lord I think I love him
Please don’t let this go

[JOSEPH]
From the moment our eyes met
My heart said hello
But Mary if you let me
I never wanna let go

[MARY]
Joe?

[JOSEPH]
I’m gonna be the best dad to our Son, Mary
I’m gonna be brave and I’m gonna be strong
An angel came and he told me the truth
Now there’s nothing I want more
Than to never let go of you

[MARY]
Then I’ll never let go of you

[MARY & JOSEPH]
At the moment our eyes meet
My heart speaks the truth
I never wanna let go of you
Oh, I never wanna let go of you