[Chorus: Luke Nagel]
You caught me off guard
Permanent scar
Fallin' away
If only you'd stay, if only you'd stay
Don't give up on me
And all we could be
If only you'd stay
If only you'd stay
Remember when we used to
Say that it was meant to be?
If only right now we could live in that dream
Don't give up on me
And all we could've be
If only you'd stay
If only you'd stay

[Verse: Laeland]
Just let me out
I tried and tried so hard to keep you here
It truly means so much to me, but
If I'm being honest
We don't got no way to solve it
Please just remember that promise
You left a pеrmanent scar on my heart
[Chorus: Luke Nagel, Laeland & Both]
You caught me off guard (Caught mе off guard)
Permanent scar (Permanent scar)
Fallin' away (Fallin' away)
If only you'd stay
If only you'd stay
Don't give up on me
And all we could be
If only you'd stay
If only you'd stay
Remember when we used to (Used to)
Say that it was meant to be?
If only right now we could live in that dream
Don't give up on me
And all we could be
If only you'd stay
If only you'd stay, if only you'd stay
(If only you'd stay)