[Verse 1]
You always had me in the palm of your hand
I don't know if I'll ever see you again
Why

I thought I had you in the palm of my hand
I thought about it and now I understand
Why

[Chorus]
You were always looking at me sideways
Tripping on me all day, puzzling you
You were always looking at me sideways
Tripping on me all day, puzzling you

[Verse 2]
I'm not the kind of girl that likes to hold hands
I tend to run from it as fast as I can
Why

I couldn't sleep the first night I let you in
I said I didn't wanna see you again
I lied

[Chorus]
You were always looking at me sideways
Tripping on me all day, puzzling you
You were always looking at me sideways
Tripping on me all day, puzzling you

[Bridge]
Never told you this
But I think it's true
We were always me
We were never you

I don't wanna say you were bad for me
Wonder if you'd say you were sad to leave?
I don't wanna say you were bad for me
You were never

[Chorus]
You were always looking at me sideways
Tripping on me all day, puzzling you
You were always looking at me sideways
Tripping on me all day, puzzling you