[Intro: Kyle Trewartha]
(The first time)

[Verse 1: Kyle Trewartha]
How did we get so far removed?
I never thought that’d be me and you, no
Wish we could see two points of view, oh
All our stupid shit broke us right in two

[Pre-Chorus: Kyle Trewartha]
Since we gave up, we've been running in the same place
Yeah, I miss you and I think you feel the same way
How you been, though? 'Cause I've been thinking
I've been thinking, I've been thinking

[Chorus: Kyle Trewartha & Robinson]
Wanna get you back on my lips
And if you forget, I forgive
'Cause I never do things right the first time
All the words we've said, take 'em back
Didn't mean 'em, no, not like that
You know I never do things right the first time

[Verse 2: Robinson]
You know I love to overthink
Getting lost, no apologies
Holding on when I shouldn't be, no
Should have tried and should have let you in
[Pre-Chorus: Kyle Trewartha]
Since we gave up, we've been running in the same place
Yeah, I miss you and I think you feel the same way
How you been, though? 'Cause I've been thinking
I've been thinking, I've been thinking

[Chorus: Kyle Trewartha & Robinson]
Wanna get you back on my lips
And if you forget, I forgive
'Cause I never do things right the first time
All the words we've said, take 'em back
Didn't mean 'em, no, not like that
You know I never do things right the first time
The first time