[Verse 1]
Seems like you already know
I'd love to have your name and a moment alone
You whisper that you'd have no other way
So I take you by your waist and head for the door
But then you stop and look me up and down, as if to say
"Boy you better prepare yourself, for your legs are gonna shake."
And I was all but clay within your hands
You had me line and sinker, hopeless in romance

[Pre-Chorus 1]
I felt your current pull me under
But you held your hand out
Now you're the only one who knows my future
Lift me up, or let me drown

[Chorus 1]
Miss Erray, you won't get the best of me
You drop them a line, they take the bait
And I will not make that same mistake
Oh, Miss Erray, you know just how to make me stay
And when I finally get ahead, I fall right back in your bed

[Verse 2]
Is this really how you'll make it up to me?
With a little more fire, a little more love between the sheets?
I will never be the sad and lonesome creep
Who gets off on the awkward pause
That only break up sex can bring
[Pre-Chorus 2]
Just one more to remember
And one more just for fun
Baby, give me one more for forever
So I can fill this void until the next

[Chorus 1]
Miss Erray, you won't get the best of me
You drop them a line, they take the bait
And I will not make that same mistake
Oh, Miss Erray, you know just how to make me stay
And when I finally get ahead, I fall right back in your bed

[Bridge]
You play the game so well
But what's your game plan
When time spoils those goods you sell?

[Chorus 2]
Miss Erray, you won't the best of me
You drop them a line, they take the bait
And I will not make that same mistake
Oh, Miss Erray, you can no longer make me stay
Because I've found myself again a new place to lay my head

[Outro]
So how you gonna make it up to me?
So how you gonna make it up to me?
(So how you gonna make it up to me?)