[Verse 1]
Stay for me, my heart on your sleeve
Tread carefully and I'll never leave
False memories make it hard to believe
But knowing my half of my tale isn't easy for me
Overflow, love comes at a cost
You'll never know how much has been lost
I'll try to let it go, my fingers are crossed
I show you my pretty scars, they make us whatever we are

[Chorus]
My (Oh my, oh my, oh my)
Please don't make me cry, oh, my baby
All these reasons why
Please don't make me cry, oh, my baby
Don't you make me

[Verse 2]
History has secrets to keep
This mystery is barely skin deep
You won't find another dream if you don't get no sleep
If we're gonna make this love, just read what's written above, oh

[Chorus]
My (My, yeah)
Please don't make me cry, oh, my baby
All these reasons why (Yeah, yeah)
Please don't make me cry, oh, my baby (Make me cry)
Don't you make me
[Bridge]
You'll see, oh, cry
All these reasons why
Please don't make me cry, yeah

[Outro]
(Oh, no) No, no, no
Don't make me, yeah
My (My, yeah)
Please don't make me cry, oh, my baby (Make me cry, baby)
All these reasons why (All these reasons why)
Please don't make me cry, oh, my baby (Please)
Don't you make me
My (Oh)
Please don't make me cry, oh, my baby
All these reasons why (All these reasons why, oh, no, no, no)
Please don't make me cry, oh, my baby (Please)
Don't you make me