I used to hear your favorite band on my free time
So we can play it in your car and scream the rhymes
Used to imagine what would happen if you were mine
My friends would ask, what's with the sexual tension?
The bubble made of love and fear of rejection
They saw right through my masochistic obsession

No, we weren't together, but it felt like it
I was jealous, you were possessive, what's the difference?

I wish I could still be your Secret Lovergirl
When we weren't just friends cause the lines were way too blurred
I know, you know, we know, it's not the same anymore
You said it's over and you walked right out the door
So now I'm not your Secret Lovergirl anymore

I miss the way the sunlight painted you golden
Our smiles kept the secrets that we're still holdin'
I know we're over, but I swear I'm still hopin'

No, we weren't together, but it felt like it
I was jealous, you were possessive, what's the difference?

I wish I could still be your Secret Lovergirl
When we weren't just friends cause the lines were way too blurred
I know, you know, we know, it's not the same anymore
You said it's over and you walked right out the door
So now I'm not your Secret Lovergirl anymore
I really miss you
Miss what we had too
Seventeen, everything felt so new
I wish we could still be in your car singing
Holding on to something bigger than we could ever be

I wish I could still be your Secret Lovergirl
When we weren't just friends cause the lines were way too blurred
I know, you know, we know, it's not the same anymore
You said it's over and you walked right out the door
So now I'm not your Secret Lovergirl anymore