[Verse 1]
And your star was there
You light up for me
You didn't want me to see
You left quietly (silently)
Now just a million eyes
They won't hide tonight
And the stars align
Light the way to love's demise

[Chorus]
I've been having the strangest feeling
That you walked out on me one evening
Walk the plank and meet the sharks
Let them cut and eat my heart
I've been having the strangest feeling
That you walked out on me one evening
Walk the plank and meet the sharks
Let them cut and eat my heart

[Verse 2]
A single tear just dropped into the ocean of your hands
You left me open now I'm hoping that you'll try to understand
Water's calling from me there's no way I can pretend
That you were coming back to get me
Now the moon will lead me in
So distant, over in an instant
You're the echo, you were here only yesterday
Where are you going? I always thought you'd stay
Make that fire; let it burn the sky away
[Chorus]
I've been having the strangest feeling
That you walked out on me one evening
Walk the plank and meet the sharks
Let them cut and eat my heart
I've been having the strangest feeling
That you walked out on me one evening
Walk the plank and meet the sharks
Let them cut and eat my heart

[Verse 3]
I approach and I emphasize
The face that I tend to hide
The closer I get you fade, you were here only yesterday
And I know I try to forget those nights, all those nights
You know I've tried

[Chorus]
I've been having the strangest feeling
That you walked out on me one evening
Walk the plank and meet the sharks
Let them cut and eat my heart
I've been having the strangest feeling
That you walked out on me one evening
Walk the plank and meet the sharks
Let them cut and eat my heart
Let them cut and eat my heart