[Verse 1: Ian; Ian & Niki]
I really wish I could be dancing with you
Only to find you're in another room
If I could rate the night from one to ten
How should I quantify standing by the chocolate fountain
Basically all night
Woah, oh, oh

[Pre-chorus: Ian; Ian & Niki]
You know I’d say there's butterflies in this stomach of mine
But they're covered all in chocolate like it’s Halloween night
And speaking of scary things
Can I just say one thing on my mind?

[Chorus: Ian; Ian & Niki; (Niki)]
There's no such thing as playing your cards right (ahh)
Or waiting for that perfect moment tonight
In hindsight (ahh), it took a couple tries
To get it all right, but in my mind (ahh)
Seeing you under these lights
Maybe next time
Maybe next time

[Verse 2: Ian; Ian & Niki]
I really wish I could be closer, too
Like how you're laughing with your family, and I mean
All these things are true
I wish I could get to know you
Woah, oh, oh
[Pre-Chorus: Ian; Ian & Niki]
You know I'd say there's butterflies in this stomach of mine
But they're covered all in chocolate like it's Halloween night
And speaking of scary things
Can I just say everything?

[Instrumental]
Woah, oh, oh
Woah, oh, oh
Woah, oh, oh
Woah, oh, oh

[Chorus: Ian; Ian & Niki; (Niki)]
(ahh) It's the way that you look at roses
(ahh) The way you look, but you do not know this
(hindsight, ahh) The way you talk about growing lilacs
(my mind, ahh) The way that you smiled back
(ahh) It’s the way that you look at stars and
(ahh) The way you lay down and sing ’Chasing Cars' and
(hindsight, ahh) The yellow tape you put on your shoulders
(my mind, ahh) Gives you a reason not to feel any colder
It’s the way you say "hello" (hello, hello, hello)
You know it's different when it comes from you
Do you go home with the feeling too?
Honey stay, honey stay (stay)
You know I wake up with the thought of you
Honey stay, honey stay (stay)
Shouldn't build my dream 'round you, but I do
[Outro: Ian & Niki]
It’s the way that we fell in love and
The way you gave me love and I gave love back
I hate to think that we might not be ready
Yet this is anything but ordinary