[Verse 1]
If I met you on the way back
Coming from a space craft
Would you tell me that you think I'm pretty?
If we met when we were in high school
Would your nerves reveal you
Sweaty palms that hold me on our prom night?

[Pre-Chorus]
Oh, I believe
My destiny leads me back to you
In every lifetime

[Chorus]
Why didn't you fight for me?
How could you just let me leave?
I'd been waiting all my life to find you
Why didn't you fight for me?
How could you just let me leave?
Now I have to die again to find you

[Verse 2]
If we were living in the 80s
Feathered hair and lazy
Would your metal band write songs about me?
What if we were both much older
Life had turned you colder
Would my voice melt all your cynicism?
[Pre-Chorus]
Oh, I believe
My destiny leads me back to you
In every lifetime

[Chorus]
Why didn't you fight for me?
How could you just let me leave?
I'd been waiting all my life to find you
Why didn't you fight for me?
How could you just let me leave?
Now I have to die again to find you

[Liz:] Hi, moon?
[Louie:] Hi, sun
[Liz:] Does it really have to be over?
[Louie:] If we had it once, it won't ever go away

[Bridge]
Now the sun is setting down
The moon'll come around
The palest light, I know it shines on you
At least we have the stars
No matter where we are
'Cause somewhere out there you and I are true
[Chorus]
Why didn't you fight for me?
How could you just let me leave?
I'd been waiting all my life to find you
Why didn't you fight for me?
How could you just let me leave?
Now I have to die again to find you