[Verse 1]
Sit me down and say you're having a baby
You caught me off of my guard
Like the time you smashed my thumb with a hammer
And then Dad came running through the yard

[Chorus]
But you were so kind
Even though none of your friends ever were
You had faith that even I could one day be made whole
And I know it's a pain how I can act like I know everything

But you carried me up
When the mountains were steep
And you kept me afloat when the waters were deep

So I'll do what I can to be the brother you need
Thank you, Seth, for being a brother to me

[Verse 2]
You and I could read the scriptures daily
And we'd still probably never agree
You say Joshua was a mighty leader
Well, he's still an asshole to me

[Chorus]
But you were so kind
Even though none of your friends ever were
You had faith that even I could one day be made whole
And I know it's a pain how I can act like I know everything
But you carried me up
When the mountains were steep
And you kept me afloat when the waters were deep

So I'll do what I can to be the brother you need
Thank you, Seth, for being a brother to me

[Verse 3]
And our lives, they keep us all apart til' the holidays
So I've come to realize that having such a tender heart, it's a curse
As much as it's a blessing, right?
Am I right?
Am I right?
Am I right?

[Chorus]
But you were so kind
Even though none of your friends ever were
You had faith that even I could one day be made whole
And I know it's a pain how I can act like I know everything

How I can act like I know everything. (It's a pain.) (x12)