[Verse 1: Johnny Stevens]
Why am I fucking up so bad?
What am I even doing?
When am I ever gonna learn?
What it is she already knows

[Bridge]
Baby, I met you in downtown Chicago
But I, I had to drive away the very next day
So I flew your pretty ass to New York City
Then I, I left you in L.A

[Chorus]
Was it love? Or my fantasy?
Was it real? Or just a dream?

[Verse 2: Johnny Stevens]
Remember one night getting too fucked up in the Hamptons at Tom's
I fell off his bike and girl, you laughed at me so hard
Spent a whole week getting drunk on the dunes of Cape Cod, that's when you met my father

[Chorus]
Was it love? Or my fantasy?
Was it real? Or just a dream?
Was it love? Or my fantasy?
[Verse 3: Johnny Stevens]
'Cause sometimes you get so angry
And I take it personal
And I should've known
That you were only hurting
'Cause life can be uncertain
When you're only 19 years old

So it's another late night out here in California
And I'm, I'm burying my pain into somebody else
And now you're back at home living with your mama
Got my first record sitting on your shelf

[Chorus]
Was it love? Or my fantasy?
Was it real? Or just a dream?
Was it love? Or my fantasy?
Was it real?

[Bridge]
Well, baby, I met you in downtown Chicago
But I had to drive away the next day
So I flew your pretty ass to New York City
Then I, I left you in L.A