[Verse 1]
As we were talking outside, it was cold
We were shivering, yet warmed by the subject matter
"My wife is in the next room
We've been having troubles, you know
Please, don't tell her or anyone
But I need to talk to somebody"
You said, "Wouldn't it be a shame if I knew how great I was
Five minutes before I died?
I'd be filled with such regret before I took my last breath"
And I said, "You're willing to tell me this now
And you're not gonna die any time soon"
And I said, "I haven't been eating chicken or meat or anything"
And you said, "Yes, but you've been wearing leather"
And laughed and said, "We're at the top of the food chain
And yes, you're still a fine woman"
I cringed

[Chorus]
I was hoping
I was hoping we could heal each other
I was hoping
I was hoping we could be raw together

[Verse 2]
We left the restaurant where the head waiter, in his sixties, said "Goodbye, sir
Thank you for your business, sir
You're successful and established, sir
And we like the frequency with which you dine here, sir
And your money"
And when I walked by, they said, "Thank you too, dear"
I was all pigtails and cords
And there was a day when I would've said something like
"Hey, dude, I could buy and sell this place, so kiss it"
I too once thought I was owed something
[Chorus]
I was hoping
I was hoping we could challenge each other
I was hoping
I was hoping we could crack each other up

[Verse 3]
I too thought that, when proved wrong, I lost somehow
And I too once thought life was cruel
And it's a cycle, really
You think I'm withdrawing and guilt-tripping you
I think you're insensitive, and I don't feel heard
And I said, "Do you believe we are
Fundamentally judgmental, fundamentally evil?"
And you said, "Yes"
I said, "I don't believe in revenge
In right or wrong, good or bad"
You said, "Well, what about that man that I saw handcuffed
In the emergency room, bleeding after beating his kid
And she threw a shoe at his head?
And I think what he did was wrong
And I would've had a hard time feeling compassion for him"
I had to watch my tone for fear of having you feel judged

[Chorus]
I was hoping
I was hoping we could dance together
I was hoping
I was hoping we could be creamy together