[Verse 1]
Given the reasons, given the choices we made
Given the violence and the soul I was hoping you'd save
I've spent my life looking for you, a devil waiting to stray
Don't tell me that I've thrown it all away

[Chorus]
Show me a sign
Or give me a belief that's believable
Love, throw me a line
I need more than a miracle
There's nothing that I wouldn't give to hold you
To heal so this heart understands
I need a secondhand hallelujah
And one more last chance

[Verse 2]
I'd always hoped for redemption, held onto be helped
I thought your love could be the exception, to pull me out of this hell
But a heart's still on fire with broken desire
I swear I only wanted to stay
Don't tell me that I've thrown it all away

[Chorus]
Show me a sign
Or give me a belief that's believable
Love, throw me a line
I need more than a miracle
There's nothing that I wouldn't give to hold you
To heal so this heart understands
I need a secondhand hallelujah
And one more last chance
[Bridge]
I need a secondhand hallelujah
A prayer that's got something to say
Don't tell me that I've thrown it all away

[Chorus]
Show me a sign
Or give me a belief that's believable
Love, throw me a line
I need more than a miracle
There's nothing that I wouldn't give to hold you
To heal so this heart understands
I need a secondhand hallelujah
And one more last chance
I need a secondhand hallelujah
And one more last chance