I must have been too good to be true
So trusting and so naive
You must have laughed when you said I love you
And I honestly did believe

The night I whispered don't be afraid
I could've sworn it was love we made

Baby, you sure fooled me
Had me going right up to the end
Baby, you sure fooled me
But I bet you no one's ever gonna fool me again

I thought you shared the feelings I felt
From the very first time we kissed
But you were just amusing yourself
Adding one more heart to your list

I never thought I could be so dumb
But you were just as smooth as they come

Baby, you sure fooled me
Had me going right up to the end
Baby, you sure fooled me
But I bet you no one's ever gonna fool me again
The night I whispered don't be afraid
I could've sworn it was love we made

Baby, you sure fooled me
Had me going right up to the end
Baby, you sure fooled me
But I bet you no one's ever gonna fool me again