[Verse 1: Katelyn Tarver]
I said I wouldn't call you
But that's what I did
As soon as I landed
I couldn't resist
And I'm getting real good at
Bringing you up
And pretending it's normal
But I do it too much

[Pre-Chorus: Katelyn Tarver]
I lie to all of my friends
I swear we're better off friends
But it's getting harder for me to hide it
I can't

[Chorus: Katelyn Tarver & Will Anderson]
I should know not to call you
I should know I'm only making it worse
Guess I'm not strong enough
I should know better
I should know better
I can't throw out the pictures
Can't believe that it wouldn't have worked
Can't stop looking you up
I should know better but there's no better than you
[Verse 2: Katelyn Tarver & Will Anderson]
I've been waking up early
I've been writing shit down
And I'm going to therapy
I don't know if it helps

[Pre-Chorus: Katelyn Tarver & Will Anderson]
I lie to all of my friends
I swear you're outta my head
But it's getting harder for me to hide it
I can't

[Chorus: Katelyn Tarver & Will Anderson]
I should know not to call you
I should know I'm only making it worse
Guess I'm not strong enough
I should know better
I should know better
I can't throw out the pictures
Can't believe that it wouldn't have worked
Can't stop looking you up
I should know better but there's no better than you

[Bridge: Katelyn Tarver & Will Anderson]
Yeah I should know better
Ooh
I should know better
I lie to all of my friends
I swear you're outta my head
Outta my head
[Chorus: Katelyn Tarver & Will Anderson, Katelyn Tarver]
I should know not to call you
I should know I'm only making it worse
Guess I'm not strong enough
I should know better
I should know better
I can't throw out the pictures
Can't believe that it wouldn't have worked
Can't stop looking you up
I should know better but there's no better than you