[Verse 1]
He was really showing off on a Sunday
A sight I've never seen
He had the sun lighting up over your face
Clouds were cotton candy pink
It was over with a kiss and
I was on a new religion
Hard to wrap my mind after all this time
Never knew what I was missing

[Chorus]
I could find Him in the sky
I could find Him in a pew
But, girl, I found mine in your five-foot-five baby blues
Got me praying you're the one that's staying
And I'm the one you'll always choose
When you say my name, I know it's true
It's gotta be God talking to me through you

[Post-Chorus]
(Oh, to me through you)

[Verse 2]
Wanna memorize your lines like the verses
Like you're every red letter word
You're a whisper in the wind and I heard it
Some things you can't learn in church
[Chorus]
I could find Him in the sky
I could find Him in a pew
But, girl, I found mine in your five-foot-five baby blues
Got me praying you're the one that's staying
And I'm the one you'll always choose
When you say my name, I know it's true
It's gotta be God talking to me through you

[Post-Chorus]
(God talking to me through you)
(God talking)

[Bridge]
You must be one of His favorites
After all that time He spent
So I sure don't wanna waste it
On an angel that Heaven sent

[Chorus]
I could find Him in the sky
I could find Him in a pew
But, girl, I found mine in your five-foot-five baby blues
Got me praying you're the one that's staying
And I'm the one you'll always choose
When you say my name, I know it's true
It's gotta be God talking to me through you