[Verse 1]
Wish I could feel what I can't see
Float like a butterfly, scream like a banshee
Something's hiding in the pantry
But I can't find it so would you please
Enchant me? Give me a potion
For my devotion to the emotion

[Pre-Chorus]
I've yet to surrender to tales of forever
But never say never, my dear

[Chorus]
Can you make me believe it?
At night when I call for the magic
'Cause I just wanna feel it
When things go bump in the attic, baby
Like a rabbit pulled from a hat
Or that any true love can match
Can you help me to see it
'Cause I want to believe in the magic

[Verse 2]
Cast all your spells onto me
Touch me with your wand till the light shines through me
Come on, baby, let's get spooky
I don't know if it's real, but I want it to be
If there's an omen, I wanna know when
My eyes are open
[Pre-Chorus]
I've yet to surrender to tales of forever
But never say never, my dear

[Chorus]
Can you make me believe it?
At night when I call for the magic
'Cause I just wanna feel it
When things go bump in the attic, baby
Like a rabbit pulled from a hat
Or that any true love can match
Can you help me to see it
'Cause I want to believe in the magic

[Bridge]
Fairy tales and sleeping beauties
Magic like what's in the movies
Want to know it absolutely
Like you do, like you do
But I felt something when you held me
Maybe one more kiss could help me
Close your eyes, your lips will tell me
If it's true, if it's true
Ooh, ooh, baby

[Chorus]
Can you make me believe it?
At night when I call for the magic
'Cause I just wanna feel it
When things go bump in the attic, baby
Like a rabbit pulled from a hat
Or that any true love can match
Can you help me to see it
'Cause I want to believe in the magic
[Outro]
'Cause I want to believe in the magic
'Cause I want to believe in the magic