[Chorus]
Oh, Natalie
Why are you so cruel?
Oh, Natalie
I can't get over you
You know I miss when we'd kiss and it'd smear your lipstick
Oh, Natalie
Why did I let you leave?

[Pre-Chorus]
Keep me up
You keep me up, keep me in trouble

[Chorus]
Oh, Natalie
You keep me up, keep me in trouble
Oh, Natalie
You keep me up, keep me in trouble

[Verse 2]
It's been a week or fifteen
Natalie hasn't said a word to me
And I keep singing to the mirror
"Why do you hurt so much?"
Help me understand your pain, your ache, your loving, ooh-ooh
[Pre-Chorus]
Keep me up
You keep me up, keep me in trouble

[Chorus]
Oh, Natalie
You keep me up, keep me in trouble
Oh, Natalie
You keep me up, keep me in trouble
Oh, Natalie
(Miss me, miss me, kiss me, kiss me)
Oh, Natalie
(Miss me, miss me, kiss me, kiss me)

[Outro]
Oh, Natalie
Oh, Natalie