[Verse 1]
Are you scarred by what he put you through?
Is that why you treat me like you do?
You keep building walls that i can't break through
What can i do to prove myself to you?

[Pre-Chorus]
Just because he wasn't faithful doesn't make me a cheater
Just because he just wasn't true doesn't make me a liar

[Chorus]
Can't you see that he ain't me? (he ain't me)
This is now how it's supposed to be
No way i can win, guilty until proven innocent
Now I'm paying for his sins

[Verse 2]
The shouting seeming all like deja vu
Cause i can't stand the thought of hurting you
But you keep pushing me farther away
Even when I'm begging you to stay

[Pre-Chorus]
Just because he wasn't faithful doesn't make me a cheater
Just because he just wasn't true doesn't make me a liar

[Chorus]
Can't you see that he ain't me? (he ain't me)
This is now how it's supposed to be
No way i can win, guilty until proven innocent
Now I'm paying for his sins

[Refrain]
It's unfair to compare
Every time you needed me I've been right there
I just know i can't hold on
Unless you let it go

[Chorus]
Can't you see that he ain't me? (he ain't me)
This is now how it's supposed to be
No way i can win, guilty until proven innocent
Now I'm paying for his sins
Can't you see that he ain't me? (he ain't me)
This is now how it's supposed to be
No way i can win, guilty until proven innocent
Now I'm paying for his sins