[Verse 1]
Were you nervous?
Lying in our bed
That you hurt us
Would you do it all again?
Was it easy?
To say you love me still

'Cause I followed you to a side of town
To a parking lot when my heart broke down
She was standing there in a dark red dress
And you kissed her cheek and now I’m a mess

[Pre-Chorus]
'Cause I
I should have known by now
I should have known that you would never put me first
That loving you was gonna hurt

[Chorus]
Oh, Why
I should have known, I should have known
I should have known, I should have known
I should have known, I should have known by now

[Verse 2]
When I met you
You were seeing someone else
But you told me
It was nothing serious
It was easy to be with me instead
So I guess I got what I deserve
It's twisted now
The tables turned
I was running blind
I was cheating faith
But I’ve only got myself to blame

[Pre-Chorus]
Oh, Why
I should have known by now
I should have known that i would fall for every word
That loving you was gonna hurt

Oh, I
I should have worked it out
I should have learned to trust my doubts instead of you
But I can't stand to face the truth

[Chorus]
Oh, Why
I should have known, I should have known
I should have known, I should have known
I should have known, I should have known by now

[Breakdown]
Cause when I saw you
In the parking lot
I stopped and stared
Couldn't help but watch
[Pre-Chorus]
Cause, I
I should have known by now
I should have known that you would never put me first
That loving you was gonna hurt

Oh, I
I should have worked it out
I should have learned to trust my doubts instead of you
But I can't stand to face the truth

[Chorus]
Oh, Why
I should have known, I should have known
I should have known, I should have known
I should have known, I should have known by now

I should have known, I should have known by now