[Verse 1: BENEE]
We can keep this up, just stay quiet
Been sneaking around, no one's found out
Seeing so much more of you now
I guess that we've lasted 'cause no one's been let in

[Pre-Chorus: Johnny Orlando]
'Cause people talk
And rumors walk
Let's keep it between us
So please, don't

[Chorus: Johnny Orlando]
Don't ever say what it is, don't put a label on it
'Cause if we let 'em all in, that just takes the fun out of it
There's a thrill in the secret, only if we can keep it
If we let 'em all in, that just takes the fun out of it
Don't ever say what it is, don't put a label on it
'Cause if we let 'em all in, that just takes the fun out of it
There's a thrill in the secret, only if we can keep it
If we let 'em all in, that just takes the fun out of it

[Verse 2: Johnny Orlando]
Thought it'd be over by the end of the summer (Summer)
But now it's almost October, you're still staying over
We're on the edge of blowing our cover (Cover)
Every time we get closer, ooh, I wanna know you
[Pre-Chorus: BENEE]
'Cause people talk (They talk)
And rumors walk (They walk)
Can we keep it between us? ('tween us)
So please, don't

[Chorus: Johnny Orlando]
Don't ever say what it is, don't put a label on it
'Cause if we let 'em all in, that just takes the fun out of it
There's a thrill in the secret, only if we can keep it
If we let 'em all in, that just takes the fun out of it

[Post-Chorus: Johnny Orlando]
Oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh, that just takes the fun out of it
Oh-oh-oh-oh
Oh-oh-oh, that just takes the fun out of it

[Bridge: Johnny Orlando, BENEE]
We could go anywhere you wanna go
Look up at the stars, they're beautiful
Anything you wanna be
Baby, please
Will you kiss and tell?
All the others do
They just run their mouths (Baby, please)
Can we keep it this chill? (Can we keep it this chill?)
[Chorus: Johnny Orlando]
Don't ever say what it is (Can we keep it this chill?), don't put a label on it
'Cause if we let 'em all in (Can we keep it this chill?)
But there's a thrill in the secret (Can we keep it this chill?), only if we can keep it
If we let 'em all in, yeah
Don't ever say what it is, don't put a label on it
'Cause if we let 'em all in (That just takes the fun out of it), yeah
There's a thrill in the secret, only if we can keep it
If we let 'em all in (That just takes the fun out of it)