[Intro: Eric Holljes]
I never knew
I never knew that everything was falling through
That after all these years I'd still be calling you
To try to sell you on the thought of coming back to me

[Verse 1: Mike Posner]
Baby girl, yeah, you were my first
But you've always been my favorite girl
And I just so happened to break up with my latest girl
So I think you should come over and be my latest girl
Latest girl
All I know is I still feel the same way
That I felt so long ago
And even though I fuck other girls
Now I don't want them, so
We can pretend that were right back in 2000 you
2000 you, hey, hey

[Hook: Eric Holljes]
Everybody knows I'm still not over you
Not over you
And every time I lose a girlfriend
I call you, yeah, I call you

[Verse 2: Mike Posner]
Walk with me, I made a few more beats
Since the last time you done talk to me
I got a few more connects in the game
But that's not all I need
Remember back in the day
You had a monster phone bill
From calling me
Why you stop calling me?
Remember, babe
I wrote you all those love notes in 7th grade
And I hope you threw those out
When we went out separate ways
Cause I don't want to see them up for sale on eBay
Don't put them on eBay, hey, hey
[Hook: Eric Holljes]

[Bridge: Mike Posner] [x2]
You were my first girl
So won't you be my last girl?
Hey, first girl
Won't you be my last girl?

[Hook: Eric Holljes]