[Verse 1]
Baby, I'm sorry to call you so late
Oh, I forget I can't call you that name
Still make those slips all of the time
Don't know when I'll get better
I think to the night that you handed me back
The records we shared and the life that we had
You said in that condescending tone
"I'll never forget you"

[Chorus]
She's in your jeans, but I don't care
You were my dream, now my nightmare

[Verse 2]
At your sister's wedding I gave all that I had
Your father was cold and your mother was sad
I thought to myself they were like you and I when we last met
My love is a nail I can't pull out with pliers
The lovers I've had have been gaslighting liars
Don't know what that says about me, but I just give in
I mean it now, it's making me ill

[Chorus]
She's in your jeans, but I don't care
You were my dream, now my nightmare
[Bridge]
So call me when you break up as you always do
Can't promise I will pick up
I'm done with you

[Chorus]
She's in your jeans, but I don't care
You were my dream, now my nightmare
She's in your jeans, but I don't care
You were my dream, now my nightmare