SHARONE
Why did each love melt away before?
Heaven above turn to clay before?
He wasn't you
He wasn't you

WARREN
Why did no arms seem like home before?
Why did my eyes always roam before
What could I do?
He wasn't you


SHARONE AND WARREN
He wasn't you, and no vows ever chained me
No, he wasn't you, and goodbyes never pained me
Now I know why each affair always faded so fast!
Only with you was I born to live;
Only to you is the love I give
Love for as long as a lifetime can last

DAVID
Why did my heart never yearn before?
Flame after flame never burn before?
He wasn't you
He wasn't you
MARK
Why did champagne lose its year for me?
Love's haunting strain disappear for me?

DAVID
What could I do?

SHARONE
What could I do?

MARK
She wasn't you

WARREN
He wasn't you

ALL FOUR
Soon you'll be gone in the shadows behind me
Still there'll be the dream that will always remind me
Now I know why each affair always faded so fast!
Only with you was I born to live;
Only to you is the love I give
Love for as long as a lifetime can last