[Verse 1]
You tell me, tell me, tell me, tell me, tell me you want me
But I know you'll do anything to get a little attention
And lately, I've been doing everything to forget our history
'Cause you push me and you pull my heart in every direction

[Pre-Chorus]
When you call me up in the dead of night, saying
"Wish that we had never said goodbye"
And you're beggin' me to go and call a cab
So we can take another stab at it

[Chorus]
Every time you say
You wanna do it again
I'm fallin' right back in
I don't know how you
Always find a way
To get stuck in my head
I hate how long you've been
Underneath my skin

[Verse 2]
Now I'm sleeping over, waking up inside your apartment
We've been down this road a thousand times, I'm not tryin' to start shit
I'm so sick of all the promises you make when you're wasted
But I fall for it every time that I see you naked
[Pre-Chorus]
When you call me up in the dead of night, saying
"Wish that we had never said goodbye"
And you're beggin' me to go and call a cab
So we can take another stab at it

[Chorus]
Every time you say
You wanna do it again
I'm fallin' right back in
I don't know how you
Always find a way
To get stuck in my head
I hate how long you've been
Underneath my skin

[Interlude]
When you pull me close
I hope you know

[Chorus]
Every time you say
You wanna do it again
I'm fallin' right back in
Every time you say
You wanna do it again
I'm fallin' right back in
I don't know how you
Always find a way
To get stuck in my head
I hate how long you've been
Every time you say
You wanna do it again
I'm fallin' right back in (Underneath my skin)
I don't know how you
Always find a way
To get stuck in my head
I hate how long you've been
Underneath my skin