[Intro: (Donnie voice over)]
Let me start by sayin...
I still love you, but when you were gone, I met somebody
I don't know...
I don't know what to do. Which one?

[Verse 1:]
I never meant to be in the wrong, though I must admit that she had me gone
Caught up in believing that she was the one, I created a storm
Let me explain what's goin on
She kept me sane when you were gone
I never knew all the things she would do... they remind me of you

[Chorus:]
I know I love her, but I gotta be sure. (gotta be sure)
She reminds me of the one I adore (one I adore)
I don't wanna be confused anymore
I gotta pick one (one, one, one, one)
Which one (one, one, one)
Which one?

[Verse 2:]
I know this is strange, but let me go on
It's like the more that she stayed, the more she belonged
I wanted to escape, but it kept getting stronger and stronger
(I couldn't leave her alone)
When I met her things suddenly changed
Now I'm stuck in the middle tryin to find find my way
I'm wonderin if this is all a mistake
Nothin will ever be the same
[Repeat Chorus]

[Hook:]
Baby I'm in love (baby I'm in love)
I'm in love with her too (I'm in love with her too)
I know that is seems unfair (so unfair)
??

[Repeat Chorus]
[Outro: (Donnie voice over)]
(One, one, one, one repeated)
It wasn't supposed to be like this
I mean it was one kiss and then we made love
I'm sorry. I gotta pick one
Which one?

[Repeat Chorus]