[Verse 1: Paul]
You said that love was just a state of mind
A puzzle made of pieces you can't find
And for me you never really had the time, and
I was blind

[Verse 2: Christian]
And everything that you meant to me
Is written in the pages of my history
But it's over now as far as I can see
Suddenly

[Chorus: Ben, All]
Things are so different now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
(And now I'm caught)
And now, I'm caught in the middle
Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
(And now I'm caught)
And now, I'm caught in the middle

[Verse 3: Mark]
Moving on, she brings me brighter days
Thoughts of you are in my mind always
Like a memory that I can't erase
It's here to stay

[Chorus: Ben, All]
Things are so different now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
(And now I'm caught)
And now, I'm caught in the middle
Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
(And now I'm caught)
And now, I'm caught in the middle
[Bridge: All, Mark, Paul, Ben]
So different (It's so different)
So easy (So easy)
But I can't get over you (I can't get over you)
So different (It's so different)
So easy (So easy)
But I can't get over you (And I can't get over you)

[Chorus: Ben, All]
Things are so different now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
(And now I'm caught)
And now, I'm caught in the middle
Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
(And now I'm caught)
And now, I'm caught in the middle

Things are so different now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
(And now I'm caught)
And now, I'm caught in the middle
Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
(And now I'm caught)
And now, I'm caught in the middle
Things are so different now you're gone
I thought it'd be easy, I was wrong
And now, I'm caught in the middle
Even though I'm with someone new
All I can think about is you
And now, I'm caught in the middle