[Verse 1: Brian]
"When you come back, I won't be here"
She said, and gently pulled me near
"If you want to talk you can call
And no, it's not your fault"
I just smiled and said, "let go of me"
Now there's something I've just got to know
Did someone else steal my part?
She said, "it's not my fault"

[Chorus: Brian with Howie & AJ, All]
Then my heart did time in Siberia
Was waiting for the lie to come true
'Cause it's all so dark and mysterious
When the one you want doesn't want you too

[Verse 2: AJ]
I was drifted in between
Like I was on the outside looking in, yeah-yeah
In my dreams you are still here
Like you've always been, oh then my heart...

[Chorus: All with Nick, AJ]
Then my heart did time in Siberia
Was waiting for the lie to come true (true)
'Cause it's all so dark and mysterious (mysterious)
When the one you want doesn't want you (want you)
[Bridge: AJ with Kevin & Howie, Brian]
I gave myself away completely
But you just couldn't see me
Though I was sleeping in your bed
'Cause someone else was on your mind
In your head
When I came back she wasn't there
Just a note left on the stairs
"If you want to talk, give me a call"

[Chorus: All, AJ, Nick, (Kevin) & Brian]
Heart did time in Siberia
Was waiting for the lie to come true
(Oh yeah-yeah-yeah-hey-hey!)
'Cause it's all so dark and mysterious
(All so dark and mysterious)
When the one you want doesn't want you too
(When the one that you want doesn't want you)
Then my heart did time in Siberia (Siberia...)
(Hey yeah-eh!)
Was waiting for the lie to come true
(I've waited, I've waited!)
Cause it's all so dark and mysterious (mysterious)
When the one you want doesn't want you too
(When the one you want doesn't want you too, ooh-ooh!)
[Outro: Kevin & All]
Siberia, Siberia
When the one you want doesn't want you too