I saw a photo of you laughing in a bridesmaid's dress

The bruised bags beneath your eyes said you could use some rest

My brother thought you never looked so hot
But my brother's tastes were always a little odd



There were photos of you hanging on to some guy's arm

Sure he's taller and more handsome

But is he going bald?

I know it's absurd to get upset

I mean, I never really wanted you to begin with

When all theses men seem to see these things I don't

I want to take back your tired beauty all for my own



Jessica, oh Jessica

What happened to us?

Was it too much?

Was it not enough?

Was I happy then? I don't think I ever was



I found some photos in a shoebox I had tucked away

A vacation we ha taken to Spirit Lake

You were young and wild and free in a bikini top

I looked old and bored and stormy

But hey, it's only a snapshot



Jessica, oh Jessica

What happened to us?

Was it too much?

Was it not enough?

Was I happy then? I don't think I ever was



I don't think I ever was

I don't think I ever was

And I'll never be

No, I'll never be

No, I'll never be as happy as I like to think I was

Oh Jessica

More from Bigamy: More Songs from the Monogamy Sessions (2011)

More by Tim Kasher

All Tim Kasher songs →