[Verse 1]
Do you remember the night the AC burned out?
It was like a hundred degrees
And we laid on the couch reading old magazines

Warm pages left ink on our finger tips
You pressed a handprint on the wall in my apartment
I think I’m gonna paint over it

[Pre-Chorus 1]
After all
Why’d you call?
After all
Why’d you call?

[Chorus 1]
Who turned on the sirens?
These tears won’t put your fire out, no
Whose side are you on?
Why’d you come here if you were just gonna leave, oh

What’s this game that you’re playing?
All you’ve taken
Did it mean nothing to you?
Why are you so cruel?

[Verse 2]
Do remember the night all of the lights went out
And you threw half of my records in your car
You said, “Don’t try to call me”
That’s fine, that’s not what made this hurt so hard

Look, I’m just tryna understand why you came back now
I think you owe me that this time
Are you satisfied?

[Pre-Chorus 2]
After all
Why’d you call?
After all
Why’d you call?

Who turned on the sirens?
These tears won’t put your fire out, no
Whose side are you on?
Why’d you come here if you were just gonna leave, oh
[Chorus 2]
What’s this game that you’re playing?
All you’ve taken
Did it mean nothing to you?
Why are you so cruel?

After all
Why’d you call?
(Why’d you call, why’d you call, why’d you call, why’d you call, why’d you call?)
After all
Why’d you call?

[Outro]
Do you remember the night the AC burned out?
It was like a hundred degrees
And we laid on the couch reading old magazines

Warm pages left ink on our finger tips
You pressed a handprint on the wall in my apartment
I think I’m gonna paint over it