Christina:
Once upon a time
My story started not far from here
And when you came into mine
I couldn't help but want you to stay

Amy:
Our words were lost in the wind once again
You say that we're wrong and I know that you're right
And you want me to just walk away
But I can't let it all pass by

Christina with background vocals from Cimorelli:
Ooooh, you pulled me along
Why don't you let me go
'Cause you are so hard to forget
When you're singing my song so sweetly now
Ooooh, so sweetly now
Ooooh, so sweetly now

Lisa:
And when things go right
I can't help but think
This is how it's supposed to be
Every note that you sing
Fits so perfectly into my song
Amy:
Our words were lost in the wind once again
You say that we're wrong and I know that you're right
And you want me to just walk away
But I can't let it all pass by

Christina with background vocals from Cimorelli:
Ooooh, you pulled me along
Why don't you let me go
'Cause you are so hard to forget
When you're singing my song so sweetly now
Ooooh, so sweetly now
Ooooh, so sweetly now

Katherine:
And I'm so attached
It's nearly possible to bring me back
And they say you're too good to be true
But you're too untrue to be good
And I can't sing along
Never could

Christina with background vocals from Cimorelli:
Ooooh, you pulled me along
Why, don't you let me go
'Cause you are so hard to forget
When you're singing my song so sweetly now
Ooooh, you pulled me along
Why don't you let me go
'Cause you are so hard to forget
When you're singing my song so sweetly now
Ooooh, so sweetly now
Ooooh, so sweetly now

You're singing my song
You're singing my song so sweetly now